Why Songs Are Sabotaged: Dalits and their Music
Socially-conscious musicians from oppressed communities face targeted violence, especially if they garner mass appeal.
October 29, 2019
Image courtesy: Yogesh Maitreya
India has had numerous epiphanic moments when a singer’s songs are sabotaged, when singers have been punished for their writings. Irrespective of which political party is in power, the brahminical ethos is consistently upheld in Indian policies and governance. That is why the state perceives dalit music and musicians as a particular threat.
Socially conscious musicians from oppressed communities who envision a equitable, just and fraternal society often face implicit or explicit violence, especially if their work carries tremendous mass appeal.
This has been the fate of dalit shahirs under the Indian state. But whatever the state’s perception may be, India remains divided into thousands of castes. This has come in the way of such epiphanies—though there have been numerous—from crossing a certain threshold and taking the shape of a social revolution.
Nevertheless, the songs of dalits and dalit shahirs still bear the potential to change how we think as a society and usher in such a revolution.
It isn’t just the music. The very experiences which these songs sway to, carry the potential to shake up society. It is the life history of the dalits which brings their songs into existence. It is their experiences that gives their music a quality that seeps into the heart through the ear. Their songs and music unsettles rather than entertains a listener. That is the unique ability of dalit shahirs to touch a listener’s conscience.
The antithesis to dalit shahir’s creations are songs—especially those that emerge out of Bollywood—which entertain and thereby mar the sense-ability to perceive beauty in the desire to form an equal, just and fraternal society.
Even the songs of love imagined by dalit shahirs are woven with the thread of logic and the needle of their vision points towards an equitable society.
Hear, for example, this song written by shahir Shantanu Kamble:
With your anklets clinking, you come by the path of equality
Breaking shackles, you come, you come
People are caged in the mansion of caste
Such is the poison that destroys generations
People with flesh and bones aren’t seen
People become strangers to each other
You come, breaking and thrashing the walls of caste.
Two punch lines written by him have been, for over a decade, the anthem of protests in Maharashtra:
Dalita Re Halla Bol Na
Shamika Re Halla Bol Na
O dalits, Storm the citadel!
O workers, Storm the citadel!
Many such songs written and performed by Kamble have created a perceptible stir among youngsters and in the wider society. They are not just powerful when heard but rousing: just lisenting to them can make your blood boil.
The impact is such due to the music Kamble inherits; but it is more on account of the fact that his songs convey the truth—unapologetically, daringly. His words and songs have the capacity to elevate the understanding of a listener. They can lift one from the mundane and reactive plane to the radical and rational level. The brahminical state has never wanted this to happen, because it uses its cultural industry to prohibit the development and arrival of a radical and rational republic. Songs which pave the way for a radical and rational society are a threat to the brahmin state.
Kamble died last year in Nashik: “In 2005, he [Kamble] was accused of having links with Naxalites. He was put into police custody for almost a 100 days. It was a torturous time for him. Eventually, he was acquitted, innocent as he was. But this physically and mentally torturous period seemed to have left an effect on him which is not imaginable by many of us—simply because many of us do not possess the profundity necessary to understand shahirs like him.”1
His ambiguous arrest, the accusations he faced, were also an attempt to limit the effect of his songs and music. Such draconian moves by the brahminical state to sabotage the music of dalit shahirs only elucidates the strength of their music. Only such songs create sounds that participate in the process of revealing the truth. Coupled with Kamble’s voice, such music can dismantle prejudice and discrimination.
Two years later, in 2011, Sachin Mali and Sheetal Sathe, who were then part of the Kabir Kala Manch (KKM), an anti-caste cultural outfit, came out of hiding. (Other members of the KKM had been arrested by the police under the draconian Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act or UAPA.)
Image courtesy: Yogesh Maitreya
Sheetal, a brilliant singer, was granted bail as she was pregnant but Sachin, her husband and a remarkable poet and lyricist, was imprisoned for four years. This disjunction broke the effect of their songs and performances, if it did not affect their spirit to sing their songs against the casteist state in favour of the people, who constitute the real republic.
While in jail, Sachin wrote a collection of poetry and Sheetal kept singing them. One of the most powerful of these is Sampavila Deh Jari:
Even if you destroyed the body
The conscience won’t be destroyed
You, contractors of religion
How would you cease progress.
Sachin Mali has written several such enchanting songs, ceaselessly amplifying the anti-caste aesthetics through his music and spreading awareness about how oppression functions. They also solve the puzzles and conspiracies of history that are not known to ordinary people. In India, the songs of dalit shahirs, their lyrics and music, also explain history in a simpler language. Their is a history that has rarely been sung in popular culture of movies and music albums. Such songs were rendered by Sheetal in her alluring and ruminative voice.
Together, their songs affected people radically but also rationally. No wonder the music from such dalit artists is seen as a threat. It is lethal to discriminatory forces because it has emerged out of an egalitarian ideology. “Overall, an ideology provides adherents with a picture of the world both as it is and as it should be, and in so doing, [it] organises the tremendous complexity of the world into something fairly simple and understandable,”2 the American political scientist Lyman Tower Sargent notes in his book, Contemporary Political Ideologies: A Comparative Analysis.
This conflict between the world as it is and should be is evident in rap music of Black rappers in the United States, especially Tupac Shakur’s work. For example, in How Can We Be Free he wrote:
Now I bet some punk will say I’m racist
I can tell by the way you smile at me
Then I remember George Jackson, Huey Newton
And Geronima 2 hell with Lady Liberty.
Tupac was undoubtedly much more socially conscious and involved with the community than many other rappers and this manifests in his songs. The nature of violence, in the context Black rappers work in, has totally different premises and reasons from the dalits. But that violence and punishment surround the lives of Black rappers and dalit shahirs alike is undeniable.
My argument is not to compare Kamble and Tupac, both of whom have experienced oppression and developed an artistic vision to fight it. I want to shed light on the fact that musicians who belong to persecuted and suppressed social groups face violence precisely for envisioning justice and fraternity. If their work has the power to attract and tempt the ears of the public, they are punished for it. [Tupac was shot dead in 1996.]
The mass appeal of their songs comes from the fact that they have the potential to deepen the conscience of the masses who are made victims of the propaganda of oppressive regimes.
The popular music only poured emotionality and romanticism into people, trapping them and convincing them to believe that songs are only meant to entertain, soothe a heartbreak, or romanticise the subject. It never gave people access to clarity on history or the modes of oppression in their everyday lives. In this sense dalit shahirs awakened people from the torpor of emotionality and made them socially conscious beings.
It is exactly to prohibit the growth and development of their social consciousness that their songs are sabotaged, time after time.
1Shantanu Kamble passes away: Remembering the power, influence of the Dalit shahir's rebellion, Yogesh Maitreya, Firstpost, dated June 15, 2018.
2Contemporary Political Ideologies: A Comparative Analysis, Sargent, L.T, Homewood, IL: Dorsey Press, 1975
All translations by Yogesh Maitreya.Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are the writer's own, and do not necessarily represent the views of the Indian Writers' Forum.
Donate to the Indian Writers' Forum, a public trust that belongs to all of us.