• US Republican Party Leader Concerned Over Death Threats to Dalit Scholar, Murder of Lankesh

    "Individual freedom of speech is infringed in India"

    The Citizen

    October 16, 2017

                                                                                                                             Image courtesy :sundayguardianlive

     

    Influential United States Representative for Arizona's 8th Congressional District, Trent Franks made a passionate speech in the House against the infringement of free speech in India, mentioning the murder of journalist Gauri Lankesh at some length.

    Franks, a member of the Republican Party spoke in specific detail about death threats received by Dalit scholar Kancha Ilaiah for his book Why I am Not a Hindu. Regretting the violations of freedom of speech in India, Franks “spoke of the polarized context of modern day India, specifically dealing with the productivity of ‘the dalits’ and ‘the lower caste’ and seemingly spiritual and monetary monopoly of ‘the higher castes’.”

    The transcript of the full speech by Trent Franks:

    Thank you Mr. Speaker.

    Mr. Speaker, the first amendment of our constitution gives us this precious freedom of speech that we so cherish in America. Contrary to the heated debate in public opinion, we're in the United States rarely facing the kind of persecution that necessitated this great protection. So I rise today to shed light on the abridgement of freedom of speech that is often widely discussed but few Americans ever have to endure. Individual freedom of speech is infringed. Sharing one's views freely on the internet can be punishable, even by death. Late one evening in September, a well-known Indian journalist Gauri Lankesh was murdered outside her home. She was an establishment figure with a reputation for her fearless criticism of undemocratic elements within the parties in power. The circumstances of her death were strikingly similar to the murders of three additional Indian activists.

    And just weeks ago, another India's most prominent political journalist, Professor Kancha Ilaiah, who continuously questioning the caste social order and was threatened by BJP allied member of India's parliament. This member issued a statement that ‘the professor should be publicly hanged’. He received numerous death threats. These threats had significant effect. A mob tried to attack Professor Ilaiah with stones. Prof. Ilaiah is now under self-imposed house arrest because he's simply not safe otherwise. Was professor Ilaiah's crime significant?

    Kancha Ilaiah was called as modern day Dr. Ambedkar, the father of the Indian Constitution. The crime of Professor Ilaiah is that he was the author of "Why I am not a Hindu?" and a recent translation of his "Post-Hindu India" (2009) is what sparked the threats book was described in a polarized context of modern day India, specifically dealing with the productivity of ‘the dalits’ and ‘the lower caste’ and seemingly spiritual and monetary monopoly of ‘the higher castes’. These became more relevant in the crisis. This resulted farmers' suicides due to hopelessness and massive joblessness due to the de-monetization and economic slowdown.

    Mr. Speaker, I stand on the floor of the United States House of Representatives to state unequivocally that the United States and the entire global community is and should be deeply concerned about this threat to the life of Professor Kancha Ilaiah, one of the world's well-known intellectuals. Our trusted ally and friend, India, is better than this, Mr. Speaker. Professor Kancha Ilaiah's freedom of speech should not be infringed and his protection and that of those like him should be the utmost priority to the Indian government. I'm able to express freely this viewpoint because we have freedom of speech in this United States of America. Mr. Speaker. May we remember at what cost and for what purpose we were given this priceless freedom. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I yield back.

     


     

    First published in The Citizen.

    Donate to the Indian Writers' Forum, a public trust that belongs to all of us.