How The Schooling Process Is Displacing Our Indigenous Children
The Discrimination under the name of Education
June 22, 2017
Nelson Mandela, the great anti-apartheid revolutionary once remarked that 'Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world'. True to his sense, education in many ways is being enacted as a powerful tool of social transformation and emancipation. Today education is a fundamental right of every citizen under the Indian constitution. But, is education always transformative and emancipatory? Or does it lead us to think and act in a systematic and symmetric way?
A Foucauldian analysis of the history of education might show us, a completely different picture of its purpose and politics. Yet, the sanctity and sacredness of education remains unquestioned by various scholars, so called experts and subsequent governments. Schools as legitimate entities of education have proven to be contradictory in the very way it violates childhood and increases the sense of dependency on government structures and market driven forces.
Since Colonial rule, schools as institutions have enacted a monopoly over the process of education. In fact, it has made us look today as if there would be no education without schools.
It is this very notion of education through schooling that has to be fundamentally challenged before schools as institutions engulf the idea of education as a whole. Because, to a certain extent, one of the greatest things that schools as official institutions of education has monopolised is the process of learning. Schools, over the centuries has forced upon children a particular process of learning that does not allow them to think critically and culturally. In many ways, schools have become institutions which are directly or indirectly affiliated to certain political interference and so there seems to be a large reluctancy in adopting diverse learning systems across curriculums.
Historically, schools have been institutions which have selectively experimented various ways to discipline and promote monolithic thoughts into young minds. In many ways schooling becomes a larger embodiment of what happens in a scientific laboratory where curriculum as the metaphor of variable is experimented over the young impressionable minds. The need to look at the process of schooling as a scientific experiment of the state and other forces of oppression has never become more important than now.
Schooling as a scientific process involves categorization and compartmentalization of minds which on a whole breaks the larger way of looking at life in an inter-connected sense. In fact, to a certain sense the categorization in the schooling process represents a periodic table in a chemistry class where children are systematically alienated and segregated according to their age groups, caste, gender and what not.
The modern day process of schooling has in fact,a unanimous acceptance in alienating the children from their homes completely by accepting the residential mode of schooling process.
The Science of Schooling
Schooling as a scientific experiment of the state, which has now been taken over by market forces needs a critical analysis in terms of the very aesthetic structures on which a so called school functions. Historically, Schools as institutions of education have displaced more number of people than all of the development projects put-together. Yes, education when seen, under the garb of schooling displaces young children from their community, values and thoughts. Displacement in education needs to seen at three levels.
Let us take the example of a young DongriaKondh child being put into a residential school for the purpose of education.
The first violation that residential school education does is to separate the child from his parents and community and put him under the illusion of what we call independence. How can one be independent without his community? From what are we seeking independence from?
The second violation that a residential schooling process of education does is to alienate the child from his land, which primarily was his/her own aesthetic space of learning his/her own community values, traditions and knowledge which in every way is inter-connected to the tribe's/communities life, lifestyle, livelihood and lifecycle. The residential schooling process creates an illusionary atmosphere of learning strictly within its own conditions, like the very way an experiment is conducted in a laboratory keeping certain variables as constants. But, who decides which the variable is and which is the constant?
The third violation that any process of schooling on whole does is to propagate the myth of development through education. And it is within this ambit of development that education tries to overemphasize the role of science in seeking the truth. What experts have to understand is that science is one of the many ways of thinking and not the thought as a whole in itself.
Truth has many sides and it certainly depends upon the context and the frame through which one thinks. Adding the logic of development into education we are not only seeing a rise of epistemic fascism, but are also witnessing the slow erasure of memories in various thinking processes. In one of way or the other, the aspiration of development propagated through education is destroying various thought processes that science does not agree to and this is precisely what the Portuguese legal philosopher Boaventura de Sausa Santos calls epistemicide – The death of knowledge systems. Then, how does one account schools which are responsible for epistemicide in the name of education?
The fate of a tribe
For a Dongria Child, the schooling process not only displaces him of the community and the land but also displaces him from his own way of seeking truth i.e through nature. This three modes of displacement through schooling plus education is what I call the triple death phenomenon. The twice born concept in a hindu society has indeed historically acquired severe criticisms from various communities especially the dalits, but often one doesn't see the reverse. Bluntly put, a Dongria child has to die thrice as he undergoes the rite of passage through the process of schooling for education.
It is then, the purity of new-self emerges with the child who can be called as a mainstream citizen who no longer has an identity except being a part of the countless number of statistics that we consider as important for showcasing progress and development.
And it is this creation of the new-self that most Asharam Shala's and residential schooling models are carrying out under the disguised name of education plus schooling. The recent move of the government to privatize the residential tribal schools especially in Maharashtra has an overwhelming logic which is being silently executed as more and more young children and their parents are being trapped and discriminated under the name of education for development.
Published here with the permission from The Citizen.
Donate to the Indian Writers' Forum, a public trust that belongs to all of us.